I must admit I thought you were going to take a different direction on that one but looking into this claim has become quite interesting.
Arcades #23: Actually some crop circles have proven to be legitimate, to the point where the biology of the crops differ greatly in the circle compared to the untouched crops around the crop circle.
CH; Now you use the word "legitimate" there, this implys that there is a proven satisfactory way to distinquish between man made circles and ones made by UFOs. But is there?
I think not but we have the 'scientific proof' presented on your link. So I check it out....
Ok, after considering the evidence presented I have to disagree that this is anything like 'legitimate scientific' proof, in fact I beleive it's a lot closer to psuedo-science. Heres a coupla reasons why..
Ok first, who is this guy, he seems to have a new indentity, check wikepedias reference theres absolutely nothing about his PHD or where he got it. Maybe you can dig something up (on a non-conspiracy website,, if you can) because I can't.
The article is confusing because the story changes at the start it says he offers proof that 'at least some circles' are formed by balls of light/UFOs.
It concludes with the definitive statement 'crop circles are not made by man but by electromagnetic point sources of unknown origin. So which is it, some or all?
Then we read about the 'objective' computer program, designed by the very man using it to 'prove' his theory,, loaded much?
What Haselhoff, or the article writer has done is very clever,
The normal process for this would be
Step 1. Prove that not all crop circles are man made.
Step 2. Find a mechanism for how they might be made.
By jumping to step 2 the reader is tricked into accepting the conclusion of step 1 even though it has not been established.
Odd also that this scientific proof was only ever published ten years ago in a (to most people) widely unknown horticultural publication, you would think some others might have picked up on it by now.
Perhaps they know that this pattern of node stretching also occurs in wind damaged and lodged crops or that whirlwinds are now known to be so charged with electrical energy that some scientists are wondering if this has more to do with their cause than temp differences.
Its an entertaining story Arcades I'll give ya that but it's a long way from credible scientific proof.