The Forum Site - Join the conversation
Forums: Politics:
Animal Rights

The False Message of the New Welfarists

Reply to Topic
AuthorMessage
rogy On June 03, 2013




, United Kingdom
#1New Post! Apr 11, 2009 @ 23:42:22
For example, in the most recent edition (April 8, 2009), the following story appears:

1. ABUSE ALLEGED AT NEW ENGLAND?S LARGEST EGG FARM

State police and Maine Department of Agriculture officials raided an egg facility known as Maine Contract Farming and Quality Egg of New England on April 1st, after Mercy for Animals (MFA) filed a complaint for civil and criminal charges to be brought against the facility and workers there. An MFA investigator allegedly documented animal abuse at the facility from mid-December to February. ?It really indicated to us that there appeared to be some very deplorable and egregious animal welfare violations over there,? state veterinarian Don Hoenig said of the documentation, which included: supervisors and other workers kicking live hens into manure pits, holes in cage floors large enough for hens to fall into the pits below, hens with body parts stuck in caging including some 150 who were unable to access food or water, cages with decomposed bodies and rotting eggs, inhumanely killed hens and live hens in the garbage (see: https://tinyurl.com/cf2gaa ).

The general problem with this sort of recitation is that although it purports to be a statement of facts, it carries an implicit normative message: that there is some difference between the Maine facility, which involves ?abuse,? and other intensive egg operations. The reality is that there may be small differences but the treatment of all of the hens in the egg industry is properly characterized as nothing short of torture.

https://www.abolitionistapproach.com/?p=443
WASH On June 04, 2012




LINCOLN, California
#2New Post! May 13, 2009 @ 23:59:41
@rogy Said

For example, in the most recent edition (April 8, 2009), the following story appears:

1. ABUSE ALLEGED AT NEW ENGLAND?S LARGEST EGG FARM

State police and Maine Department of Agriculture officials raided an egg facility known as Maine Contract Farming and Quality Egg of New England on April 1st, after Mercy for Animals (MFA) filed a complaint for civil and criminal charges to be brought against the facility and workers there. An MFA investigator allegedly documented animal abuse at the facility from mid-December to February. ?It really indicated to us that there appeared to be some very deplorable and egregious animal welfare violations over there,? state veterinarian Don Hoenig said of the documentation, which included: supervisors and other workers kicking live hens into manure pits, holes in cage floors large enough for hens to fall into the pits below, hens with body parts stuck in caging including some 150 who were unable to access food or water, cages with decomposed bodies and rotting eggs, inhumanely killed hens and live hens in the garbage (see: https://tinyurl.com/cf2gaa ).

The general problem with this sort of recitation is that although it purports to be a statement of facts, it carries an implicit normative message: that there is some difference between the Maine facility, which involves ?abuse,? and other intensive egg operations. The reality is that there may be small differences but the treatment of all of the hens in the egg industry is properly characterized as nothing short of torture.

https://www.abolitionistapproach.com/?p=443


I wonder the abuse noted above. I doubt that the owners would harm their bottom line to the extent as noted!
rogy On June 03, 2013




, United Kingdom
#3New Post! May 15, 2009 @ 15:02:10
@WASH Said

I wonder the abuse noted above. I doubt that the owners would harm their bottom line to the extent as noted!



Yes, interesting. There is a common assumption that animal property owners would not abuse there property if their profits are imperiled. However, one can do lots of harmful things to animals and their biological systems will still function.

eg, births still occurred in concentration camps - and so will the laying of eggs (apologies to those who find this analogy distrurbing or insulting).


rogY
Alanna On February 13, 2010




Cincinnati,
#4New Post! May 24, 2009 @ 12:24:53
@rogy Said

The False Message of the New Welfarists


I don't get the connection between the title of your Forum and the content. Please explain what false message you are talking about and what you mean by "New Welfarists".
rogy On June 03, 2013




, United Kingdom
#5New Post! May 25, 2009 @ 17:12:14
@Alanna Said

I don't get the connection between the title of your Forum and the content. Please explain what false message you are talking about and what you mean by "New Welfarists".



The title comes from the final link in the first post.

"new welfarism" was coined by law professor and animal rights philosopher Gary Francione. It means the kind of approach adopted by PETA who call themselves an animal rights organisation but they are not inspired by animal rights philosophy. Instead they follow the utilitarian philosophy of Peter Singer (his "Animal Liberation" book has been very influential in the animal protection movement - but it is not a rights-based book).

For more on NW: https://books.google.ie/books?id=HZTpej7dGGEC&pg=PA47&lpg=PA47&dq=new+welfarism&source=bl&ots=Vz1Fc4Cr6b&sig=OINvgogMlvs09rlfzzy1fSnsS04&hl=en&ei=1M8aSqTFH4XG-AbBp5Vr&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=2
Reply to Topic<< Previous Topic | Next Topic >>

1 browsing (0 members - 1 guest)

Quick Reply
Politics Forum - Some Rudeness Allowed

      
Subscribe to topic prefs

Similar Topics
    Forum Topic Last Post Replies Views
New posts   Jokes & Humor
Wed Nov 03, 2010 @ 16:07
4 651
New posts   Jokes & Humor
Wed May 12, 2010 @ 16:37
2 392
New posts   Jokes & Humor
Sun Jan 24, 2010 @ 11:18
1 391
New posts   Random
Thu Apr 16, 2009 @ 20:16
18 2229
New posts   Animal Rights
Tue Oct 03, 2006 @ 16:00
21 1827