@Erimitus Said
C: I believe we should have 100% (or as near 100% as possible) conscription into either military service or civil service duty.
E: My hypothetical social system makes military service a requisite for citizenship. Non-citizens (i.e., residence) would have all the rights that citizens have except for voting.
I'm ok with that.
I add in (in "my world" ) the civil service duty as some can't serve in the military due to physical limitations and/or because some are "conscientious objectors" due to religion. These people should still owe service to our country... IMO... thus "civil service".
I would add in that people could buy out of their duty to serve... it would be very expensive, paid up front (no loans/no government assistance) and public knowledge kept easily accessible to all. No reason needed, just $x.00... maybe $1,000,000.00.... but one forfeits the ability to hold government office (elected or otherwise).
I would be happy to add your idea of "no service-no vote".
I wrote a thesis on this back in university... I thought it very comprehensive and reasonable... if I do say so myself (though supported by the good grade I got on the thesis and in the class).
Of course that is all a high jacking of "my" thread...which I endorse fully.