The Forum Site - Join the conversation
Forums:
Politics

Recycling

Reply to Topic
AuthorMessage
weaksauce On May 28, 2011




DFW, Texas
#1New Post! Jan 17, 2009 @ 00:51:38
For quite sometime I have been in the mindset that recycling is beneficial to the environment. Lately I have been second guessing what the media has been conveying as the cure all for our environmental woes. Naturally, I like to investigate at both sides of a topic and form my own opinion. I recently heard the other side of this topic via a show that consists of debunking what mainstream will show. During this show they made some really great points and in doing so if formed some questions of my own. Do not get me wrong I think anything we do to as the phrase goes ? reduce, reuse and recycle? is great for the environment. I feel the way we do this does not entirely encapsulate the idea of recycling.
For instance the issue of recycling paper creates by-products such as a type of bleach. What happens to this product and others created by this process? Are they recycled as well, disposed of or simply stored until we figure out what to do with them at a later time? I believe this is the same story with plastics, although I could not find a source stating this.
Enough about the processing of the actual products. What about the equipment that is used? In my area we have one truck that comes by for the trash and a separate truck that pickups our recyclables. You can already see the issue with this. Two trucks equal twice everything. Twice the fuel to operate the truck and twice the emissions. Then there is the facility itself. Is the energy that the recycling center using a green source of energy, and if not how much must we recycle to compensate for this energy consumer?
Recycling does have its immediate positive effects. The jobs that are created are without saying beneficial and help stimulate the local area.
In all, I am not saying that recycling is bad it does have this good outcomes. We take a used product and turn it in to another product that can be used again without using our earths diminishing resources. I just have questions that are a counter point to recycling.
El_Tino On October 12, 2023
booyaka!





Albuquerque, New Mexico
#2New Post! Jan 17, 2009 @ 01:02:55
@weaksauce Said

For instance the issue of recycling paper creates by-products such as a type of bleach. What happens to this product and others created by this process? Are they recycled as well, disposed of or simply stored until we figure out what to do with them at a later time? I believe this is the same story with plastics, although I could not find a source stating this.


Well, if you look at that in isolation it might sound like a bad thing. But if you consider the alternative, the "bleach products" whatever they are would end up in a landfill. So you really need to compare something with an alternative to decide what's better for the environment. I don't know what happens to the bleach products, so let's say they dispose of it in a hazardous waste dump, and compare with the alternative of not recycling.
- Recyling: bleach byproduct disposed in hazardous waste dump, no extra trees cut down.
- Not recycling: bleach byproduct in the paper ends up in your local landfill, not a hazardous waste dump. Extra trees cut down to make new paper.
So, even if there are some negative environmental effects of the recycling, they are less than simply throwing away the paper.


Quote:
Enough about the processing of the actual products. What about the equipment that is used? In my area we have one truck that comes by for the trash and a separate truck that pickups our recyclables. You can already see the issue with this. Two trucks equal twice everything. Twice the fuel to operate the truck and twice the emissions. Then there is the facility itself. Is the energy that the recycling center using a green source of energy, and if not how much must we recycle to compensate for this energy consumer?


Again, you need to compare the energy used by the facility to recycle with the energy required to create the product NEW to begin with. In the case of paper, most places in the country aren't anywhere near a paper mill that creates paper from fresh lumber, so a lot of energy is required to move the paper to its final destination. You can put a recycling facility anywhere, not just near large forests so less energy is required to ship the material to its final destination.

Quote:
Recycling does have its immediate positive effects. The jobs that are created are without saying beneficial and help stimulate the local area.


That, and your local garbage dump doesn't grow as fast.
Allyson On January 20, 2010

Deleted



, Michigan
#3New Post! Jan 17, 2009 @ 02:39:07
our recycling works with us taking it to the recycling place, it's not picked up.
Reply to Topic<< Previous Topic | Next Topic >>

1 browsing (0 members - 1 guest)

Quick Reply
Politics Forum - Some Rudeness Allowed

      
Subscribe to topic prefs

Similar Topics
    Forum Topic Last Post Replies Views
New posts   Society & Lifestyles
Poll: First unread post Recycling
Mon May 04, 2009 @ 00:36
16 1088
New posts   Technology & Internet
Thu Mar 26, 2009 @ 19:30
14 803
New posts   Environment
Wed Dec 31, 2008 @ 19:08
3 944
New posts   Environment
Fri Apr 11, 2008 @ 01:31
10 1010
New posts   Environment
Fri Mar 14, 2008 @ 22:00
4 699