Forum Index > News & Politics > Animal Rights | >> these poor animals need our help! | | |
May 09, 2008 @ 17:27:13 | #125 | knowledgeispower
Über-Commander 135 points


18/M/Toronto, Canada Join Date: May 2008 | While it is a fairly bad thing, it's not something I'm going to cry over or quit eating meat. Killing an animal for the meat I can live with or killing rodents if they're around your house I can live with. Skinning an animal while it is alive is something I don't approve of. If we were to use the animal for various things, such as meat for food and bones for tools, then skinning it for fur is fine providing it has no feeling of the skinning taking place (i.e. dead). Senseless torturing of animals (i.e. setting a cat on fire while it's alive) is something I cannot approve of. I find that just plain sick. One could say that those people have mental disorders (as I do too) so I can understand there may be some things they cannot control. I'm schizophrenic and I cant always control when I go in and out nor can I stop the deadened emotions.
That being said, if a human knows sensitive information, such as the location of a bomb, and refuse to give it, then I think torturing can be acceptable. Torturing should be a last resort to getting information, or in the medieval times, for punishment (now not as acceptable). The animals cannot determine as well as we can what is right and what is wrong, if they've done something wrong, such as a dog jumping up, a loud, firm shout of "no" is fine but not torturing the hell out of it.
If this has been unclear, I'll sum it up so it seems more clear: animals can be killed for food and skinned when dead so there is no pain at all. Torturing the animals for no reason while they're alive is wrong (if an animal is already dead from being killed then I'm unsure if setting in on fire is acceptable. On one hand, it is because it's not in any pain. On the other hand, it's degrading the animal).
I'm not supporting the torturing in any way but I'm not going to lose sleep over it, quit eating meat or be too sad to function properly. | | |
May 09, 2008 @ 18:31:54 | #134 | doubtingthomas
Mega Über-Meister 4837 points


32/M/monterey, California Join Date: Mar 2008 | Quote: Animals have nerves. Animals feel pain loneliness and fear just like we do. Humans are too selfish to accept that. Animals have hearts humans have hearts. Just because animals cant say "Stop your hurting me" doesn't mean they cant feel pain.
So what. I can accept that. I'm not seeing why we should stop what we are doing now. The ablity to convey if they are feeling pain by saying "stop that" won't stop me from eating them.
Quote: Because animals don't use human flesh as a fashion statement. Animals dont keep 89000 humans in a small cage to force breed and be murdered.
You should look at the definion of "murder" it doesn't involve what your discribing. Animals dont' use cars either, does that mean I shouldn't drive anywhere? I"m not seeing the connection your making.
Quote:
But the situation isn't reversed. We dominate and keep taking more and more. And animals have their own coat. We have perfectly good cotton.
We as humans have developed ways of taking skins from other animals instead of having our own coats of fur. We can take it off and put it back on in the form of clothing. With this adaptation we can now regulate our body temp. with no molting. Its more effecent and is yet another reason why we are the domonate species on this planet.
Cotten takes time to grow and cultivate, animals are just more effective.
Quote: if you were an animal would you like to get tortured for your furs?
I am an animal and if anyone tried to torturer me for my fur i would react with what I have been taught to defend that. Happly cows havn't figured what a machine gun is.
Quote: And what about chinchillas skinned for fur? Or racoons for the same reason. Not much meat on them huh? Not much or a reason to kill other then fashion
The goal of most humans procreate, if wearing a coonskin hat lets me do that more effectivly. Guess what i'm wearing 
Quote: We violate a cow's rights by breeding and killing her and we can violate human workers' rights if their situation places them economically vulnerable.
I'm sorry but cows don't have any rights. They are considered property. I don't feel they should have any rights other than that. Whats the point?
You seem to think they should have rights other than that. So I'll entertain what your talking about.
I'm dying to know what your perfect society would look like. Would it be world wide or only in your county. No rodeos.. no chicken fighting.. no dog fighting.. no horse races.. no dog shows..
Please discribe in great detail what at the end of the day the world picture would be if we didn't kill animals for skins and food.
You ar living in a Star Trek fantasy land where we walk over to a machine and get our protein drink wearing our cotten clothing.
Discribe to me how the people of a desert would live day to day without relying on goats for food, clothing and comerce. Discribe to me how you would destroy cultures that have been around for thousands of years because the sheep they eat need to be left alone and are in pain.
Please don't link a book, link your realistic reponse of what your future is invisioning.
 I'm David Makalaster your 10oclock news caster.... | | |
Top
|