Forum Index > Music > Punk
>> WHO WAS THE BEST, THE PISTOLS OR THE CLASH?
Reply to Topic
Search Topic
Subscription
Author Message
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 · >>

New Post! Sep 07, 2007 @ 02:25:14#1
hpuffy

Apprentice
32 points


Send PM


41/F/Glasgow, United Kingdom
Join Date: Aug 2007

To me, they both embodied the anti-establishment philosophy and frenetic energy of Punk, but lyrically I think The Clash have to be considered the best. Anyone care to disagree?

hpuffy last visited September 07, 2007
0 Kudos   

New Post! Sep 07, 2007 @ 06:58:56#2
chrill

Über Master Debater
9235 points


Send PM


17/M/Stockholm, Sweden
Join Date: May 2007

The Clash, simply because more peeps knows of them, and as I listen to em


"Oh god!"
"Please, just call me Chrill"

chrill last visited July 23, 2008
0 Kudos   

New Post! Sep 07, 2007 @ 07:01:07#3
treebee
point whore spanker
Über-Moderator
153293 points


Send PM


38/F/Escaped!!!, United Kingdom
Join Date: Oct 2005

The Clash were like the radiohead of thier day, secretly they all had university degrees and were actually good musicians.

The Sex Pistols were the Take That, manufactured to make as much cash as possible.


link [www.thebreastcancersite.com] Please click to save a life
Teresa is a doll that should be purchased for regular playtime - Googlism

treebee is online! (Last active within 2 minutes)
-1 Kudos   

New Post! Sep 07, 2007 @ 07:19:45#4
hallucinogenic_lipstick

Minister
13593 points


Send PM


31/F/Ely, Cambridgeshire, United Ki
Join Date: Jul 2006

The clash most definately...london calling and rock the casbah are genius!


If it's white, sticky and not yours dont touch it.



Confession? Go here link [grouphug.us]

hallucinogenic_lipstick last visited July 23, 2008
0 Kudos   

New Post! Sep 07, 2007 @ 07:34:40#5
chrill

Über Master Debater
9235 points


Send PM


17/M/Stockholm, Sweden
Join Date: May 2007

Rock the Casbah Love that track

(Can't say the same about, for example, Anarchy in the U.K)


"Oh god!"
"Please, just call me Chrill"

chrill last visited July 23, 2008
0 Kudos   

New Post! Sep 07, 2007 @ 14:22:48#6
rats_and_gods

Mega Über-Meister
3183 points


Send PM


31/M/Austin, Texas
Join Date: Jun 2007

I think both bands had a totally different style to their music and way they went about things. Hard to compare them really but in the end, I would have to say the CLASH (sorry Sel) due to seeming to have a more educated view within their lyrics where the SEX PISTOLS seemed to just kind of be there to piss people off. Both were great though.

rats_and_gods last visited May 28, 2008
0 Kudos   

New Post! Sep 07, 2007 @ 14:28:47#7
treebee
point whore spanker
Über-Moderator
153293 points


Send PM


38/F/Escaped!!!, United Kingdom
Join Date: Oct 2005

The pistols did do some good stuff, manufactured bands do make good stuff because its gotta sell or the whole project goes tits up. I did like the B sides much more than the crappy anarchy s**t. When they made fun songs instead of trying to be political and shocking they were good and sounded like they were having fun.


link [www.thebreastcancersite.com] Please click to save a life
Teresa is a doll that should be purchased for regular playtime - Googlism

treebee is online! (Last active within 2 minutes)
1 Kudos   

New Post! Sep 07, 2007 @ 14:35:11#8
wildething

Debater
6551 points


Send PM


47/NA/, United Kingdom
Join Date: Jul 2007

the clash are my favourites but the pistols are the ones who really out 'punk' on the map. love 'pretty vacant', it rocks!

wildething last visited February 04, 2008
0 Kudos   

New Post! Sep 28, 2007 @ 02:15:03#9
therevplague

Recruit
14 points


Send PM


16/M/,
Join Date: Sep 2007

The Clash and the Pistols were too different to say which was better, the Clash were better musicians, and the Pistols were just in your f**kin face non-stop.

therevplague last visited October 20, 2007
0 Kudos   

New Post! Sep 28, 2007 @ 04:37:42#10
hannibal

Mega Über-Meister
4585 points


Send PM


30/M/SYDNEY, Australia
Join Date: Nov 2005

bahh !!! dead kennedys are the best


it only hurts till the pain goes!!!!
Confucius Say .... man with hand in both pockets not always on the ball!

hannibal last visited <font color=#990033>12 minutes ago </font>
0 Kudos   

New Post! Sep 28, 2007 @ 05:10:31#11
vizzy

Über-Minister
16262 points


Send PM


38/F/, Florida
Join Date: Aug 2007

ahhhh I have such a soft spot for The Clash. Met my first boyfriend at a Halloween party. He was dressed in Clash garb



vizzy last visited July 23, 2008
0 Kudos   

New Post! Oct 25, 2007 @ 23:14:04#12
rockdave

Debater
6482 points


Send PM


21/M/peterboring, United Kingdom
Join Date: Oct 2007

the pistols got me in to punk so them (seeing as people have missed the point and think theyre 'manufactured'... do they know anything about the history of the pistols???) whereas the clash were on their own trip and werent even punk from london calling onward, the pistols changed musical history with one album, it took the clash their whole career and joe strummer dying for us to realise hes a moody middle cla** tosser


dyslexic bloke walks in to a bra... tommy cooper

rockdave last visited July 24, 2008
1 Kudos   

New Post! Oct 25, 2007 @ 23:20:26#13
nirvanachick

Debater
5244 points


Send PM


18/F/, New Jersey
Join Date: Mar 2007

chrill said:
Rock the Casbah Love that track

(Can't say the same about, for example, Anarchy in the U.K)


anarchy in the uk is going to be on guitar hero 3...cannot wait!!!
nirvanachick last visited February 19, 2008
0 Kudos   

New Post! Oct 26, 2007 @ 00:01:37#14
mindcontroldotgov

Commander
63 points


Send PM


26/M/Joliet, Illinois
Join Date: Oct 2007

Sid (as sexy as he is) completely f**ked the pistols... though Johnny made a come back in Public image Ltd! The Clash is just the clash they cant be beat and they can bring random people together (the ramones do that too)


“You cannot simultaneously prevent and prepare for war.” ~ Albert Einstein

mindcontroldotgov last visited November 05, 2007
0 Kudos   

New Post! Oct 26, 2007 @ 00:15:34#15
x_laura_x

Points Whore Master
63424 points


Send PM


16/F/A yellow house, United Kingdo
Join Date: Jun 2007

I like both but I'm going to say Sex Pistols


x_laura_x is online! (Last active within 5 minutes)
0 Kudos   
Reply to Topic<< Previous Topic | Next Topic >>
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 · >>

Top

TFS Time: Thu 24 Jul 2008 04:21 am CDT
Copyright © 2004-2008 Funky Llama Productions, LLC   |   Home   |   Contact   |   Privacy Policy   |   Terms of service
Proudly hosted by Liquid Web

 
The Forum Site - Your premier source for everything