The Forum Site - Join the conversation
Forums: Science:
Psychology

Situationism vs Virtue/Personality Traits

Reply to Topic
AuthorMessage
sister_of_mercy

Twinky+




London, United Kingdom
#1Old Post! Nov 23, 2011 @ 22:54:13
My psychology lecture today was quite interesting and got me thinking about the influences of behaviour.

Just wondering whether you think behaviour is influenced by the situation a person is under or whether it's just down to their 'virtues' (i.e. personality traits that are consistent on a global scale), or whether it's a bit of both?
On 51 minutes ago
alk1975

Über-Minister+




Jackson, Missouri
#2Old Post! Nov 24, 2011 @ 00:49:06
absolutely both. First, I do think that personality itself is a combination of nature and nurture. It is determined early on, and certainly newborns have a temperament of their own, but the environment during the early years definitely has an effect.

Then I believe that personality affects how you react to situations, but situations also start to change your personality.Definitely certain circumstances harden a person, reduce the ability to trust, etc.
On about 13 hours ago
TFS Advertisement
Electric_Banana

Points Whore Master+




Don't know, New Zealand
#3Old Post! Nov 24, 2011 @ 01:00:48
No matter how a person is raised or despite there base persona, the rose tints eventually get b****-slapped off their face.

Behavior and response are mostly molded from the environment.

For instance you start off in life with an innocent desire for apples but after years and years of being served bad ones eventually when you are asked "How do you like these apples?" your reply ends up being "No, thank you, I'd rather not bother with them at all."

And so behavior and response has gone from thankfully accepting the apple in eager anticipation to walking past and laughing at the person offering it.
On about 4 hours ago
annski729

Giant Donkey+




Washington, District of Columb
#4Old Post! Nov 24, 2011 @ 05:39:47
Both. That's been more or less established by the field

The same person will act differently in different situations (e.g. at a sports game vs. in a classroom) but their personality largely remains stable throughout the life span.

That being said, people tend to react remarkably similarly in the same types of situation. Social psych studies the influences of the situation, and I have always found it much more fascinating than personality psych. Personality psych was boring Look into the Milgram study, Stanford Prison Experiment, Asch's vertical line test just to name a few interesting and well-known ones.
On about 4 hours ago
Reply to Topic<< Previous Topic | Next Topic >>
Share |

1 browsing (0 members - 1 guest)