Best Metallica Album?

Master of Puppets is clearly the best. I didn't include Lulu or Beyond Magnetic on here. In my opinion, I think St. Anger is the worst.

Metallica!!!!!

There is so much greatness between Kill 'Em All and Master of Puppets but I had to pick Master.

I cast my vote on ...And Justice for All because I think it's the perfect mix between their rougher beginnings and their more mainstream 90s. The Black Album is a bit too much radio rock to be labelled their greatest. And Justice for All, however, is just brilliant. Every single track.

And Justice for All is my favorite, for sure, though Master of Puppets, Ride the Lightening, and Kill 'Em All are all fantastic.

St. Anger is definitely the worst. It's just terrible. That's why I'm really surprised at how good Death Magnetic was. And the thing is, Death Magnetic isn't that great. It just sounds really good compared to St. Anger.

Metallica sucks.

This is so true Death Magnetic is arguably their best release since the Black Album, but it's way behind their 1980s albums

I liked Master Of Puppets and Kill 'Em All

Kill 'em All is really good for a first album.

How come "The $5.98 E.P.: Garage Days Re-Revisited" isn't a choice?

Dunno. Pick that if you want.

Also, where's "S&M" the one with the orchestra? That one was pretty wicked.

My choice is the Garage Days Re-Revisited. I can't vote though because it's not a choice.

Well, S&M like Lulu is a special album. Here, I'll edit my post and add Garage Days.

[edit] well, it doesn't appear I can edit it. Oh well. Just pick a favorite out of the others.